Thursday, February 4, 2016

Never get too attached to your work

Don't forget how to dog!


One most crucial thing about level designing is to never get too attached to your work. As soon as you start thinking "This is awesome, I should never change this" or "This spot couldn't be altered, it's as good as it can be." you will most likely walk straight to the devil's trap.

The problem of this kind of thinking is that it actually kills your creativity. To be more specific.. it kills your level. You have to be ready to change those parts that you like too. You know your work better than anyone. If no player understands your point in-game it is, as gamers very frequently put it, "shit". You have to get in their heads. Otherwise you forget how to design. Just like this dog who forgot how to dog...



Creating something unique requires you to think differently than anyone else. You have to unlearn some things, you have to learn something new. Without those two elements you will create the same stuff over and over again and it never get's better. 

As the year 2015 ended with dissatisfaction with de_farm, year 2016 started with new thoughts. I decided to create de_farm all over for the fifth time. This time it will be different because I will simply iterate it as longs as I need to iterate to get the layout done. 

The main problem with the de_farm fourth version seemed to be poorly defined chokepoints. I came to that conclusion after this kind of thinking:

Feedback: "You map is shit"-->
Question: "Why?" ---->
Feedback: "I die always without even realizing where enemy was" or "enemy comes kills me from the back everytime" ---->
Question: "Why?" ---->
Feedback: "Ct rotates too fast" and "Terrorists have too many routes that they have to control before they have killed anyone".--->
Question: "Why?" --->
Feedback: "Chokepoints could be better defined." and "Timings could be fixed a little"---->
Question: "Why?"---->
Go back to the first or second feedback..

Another major problem that lead me to decision to star it over was that back in the days when I created the 3D skybox I had a problem with it (Honestly I was just an idiot and didn't fix it right a way) and I somehow managed to move everything few units off grid. That wouldn't have been a major problem otherwise but when I had to start doing some major layout changes I started fixing the problem block by block. I got pretty far with it before I realized that they all are 3 units off grid. So I ended up having either whole middle area (which was the most crucial part to change) off-grid or everything else off-grid. 


One thing with creativity is that you should never trust the first solution blindly.

With the new layout I ended up changing whole CT side of middle entirely. Also A long changed pretty much and A bombsite. I'm not still confident with A bombsite but creating that is whole another story. I also deleted almost half of the all elevations and deleted and added some routes. I finally realized one very important thing with choke point. It should be risky thing for player to go in there and before chokepoint the player(team) has to have some space to regroup and cover from enemy.

Here's the new layout.

As you can see, it has changed a lot. If you would like to follow what's going on with the map, I'll be updating mapcore thread in here.

Thursday, December 24, 2015

Reddit! community night playtesting!


It was pretty awesome..


Before


Before the playtesting my hopes were like 0. I didn't give rats ass about the map anymore and I had pretty much stopped updating this map. I was thinking more or less that everyone who take a look at it hates it.

I even started a new project after summer and created it pretty far. I messed it up already and I'm considering if I should create it all over. Anyways that's gonna be in far future since now I'm going to focus on creating demo project for kickback.com to see if my artistic style with hammer is what they want for their 1v1 maps. Anyways, back to the playtest..

Vizo (reddit playtest admin) notified me strangely often about playtest and I would have forgotten without him being so active. It somehow gave me feeling that he really wants me in there. :) Great job Vizo, thank you.

I hadn't played any reddit playtestings before. I had tried mapcore playtests but they are more like public playtests were people go critisize the work more than to test and still the feedback is minimalistic compared to testing.

What suprized me the most was that beforehand some people actually tried the map and one guy made even a video where he points out some very bad spots that I have ignored or have not noticed at all. That was great! You can find the xd's bug video here!

Anyways.. I joined Teamspeak channel and tried to figure out the whole system and I was very confused. "What should I do, where should I join.. what the heck.."

Everything cleared out pretty soon because admins were very friendly and talked great english. It was easy to understand as a non-native what they meant. (unlike it is for you who read my posts :D)

During

It was all new to me.. They picked their teams and talked in ts3 like they all knew each other. As a finn that wasn't very easy for me. And it was about to turn as a catastrophe for our team when they tried to make me our team's in-game leader. I just responded that even when I have made the map and know every inch of it I'm not very good in-game leader. ("I think I shouldn't be igl".. everything is shorter when said.. u know.. ^^)

I expected the game to be very fragmented like in mapcore playtests. But it actually worked very well. We played like it was next level of normal match making. We weren't very serious but we actually tried to play more or less as a team. There was some pauses because some guy had internet problems so people shared some feedback during breaks.

When the game was about to end one guy, TaF pointed out that middle angles are very broken and that makes whole map T-sided. I added guy as a friend and we checked some spots after playtest.

After & Feedback

With TaF we first focused to middle area. TaF pointed out that angle from kiln to window is OP for terrorists because they can see all the way to the door. Even if CT can run there faster they are forced to either stay too far away from the window area (where the true fragging would happen) or go too exposed near the window. Because as soon  as anyone spots that guy he's going to get wallbanged.

Another spot was between middle and B. He said he liked very much the idea that one guy could watch partly both middle and B. It's easy for this guy to help in the middle if there's tough situation or to hold B bombsite if guy on B long spots someone in there.

Middle area was the biggest problem during the playtest. Not only TaF felt that it's too big and angles doesn't work very well right now. Also people said that in the middle there are too much routes. I'll have to erase some points.

Also there was a timing problem on CT to B-long. B long guy wouldn't have time to get in there in time so I think I'm going to rework the CT spawn to B-long route. I may have to tweak T's timings to same place also. If I was any cleverer I would say "Time will tell.." :)

Jump from A-tree to connector-house is a bit too hard at least when it's so easy for Terrorists to just run in there.

One guy felt that buildings were too big around him. I'm not entirely sure that's the problem with map. I think the problem might be that some spots in the buildings look unrealistic like for example connector. I don't know who would ever create such a building.. I just have to rework it.. it's awful!

Upcoming fixes & changes

1. The angle from Kiln to window will be reworked. I was thinking I will do as TaF suggested that I just simply make the catwalk wooden fence go 2 meters further so that there's more cover for CT.

2. Spot between mid and B. I'm not completely sure if I'm going to change that much. I think it may be good as it is if I change T side of middle and connector a little. 

3. T warehouse, or at least the middle side shelter-roof is going to get extended a bit towards CT spawn and maybe to B side also. Also the doorway which leads directly to the logs and boxes is going to get removed. This makes terrorists to commit to the middle. They won't be just sitting behind middle boxes and wallbanging because they won't get in the middle first. It was also suggested by TaF that I would remove middle to B-long route which goes between silo and B barn.

4. It's very likely that I will change Connector to middle doorway to window or switch places of fireplace and doorway. That way the rotation times will stay same -ish.. and CT have better cover. Now that I think of it.. maybe I'll put that fireplace in the place of window dropzone so that player comes through the chimney. Also the window instead of doorway towards middle would be very good call in my opinion.

5. B-long route from CT spawn through "piggery" which looks more like henhouse will be reworked. I guess my options are
a) to remove water (which make player go a bit faster) and tweak T side timings.
b) to block route from long to piggery completely and create new route behind piggery.
c) to make route from CT to long more straight forward and block doorway to the pens.

the last option wouldn't necessarily need any timing changes on T-side of map. So it would be easiest but I think it could be smartest to create whole new route to go behind the piggery. That would provide the best cover for CT and would also make it harder for Terrorist to flank Ct from behind.

6.  To make it easier to jump in the a house (that's between mid and a.. it need a proper name -.-') I think I should add a box under the long-side window so that you can jump in with crouch jump. Also I'm going to make that other window smaller and block it so terrorists will only have one window to jump on the site but two to look and have info.

7. Visual facelifting would also be necessary for this map. That's why I may have to rework some areas like connector, piggery, a-house (that still need that name) and maybe some other parts that are something but still nothing at the moment.

8. There are a lot of spots that are wallbangable and I'm going go fix that. For now I can't say which positions are going to affect the most.


Thanks and future plans

One thing that is bothering me the most.. I have been creating this map for almost 3 years and it has so much Tophattwaffle's textures that I'm ashamed of it. Thanks a lot to THW, I love his tutorials and all but that's just something I have to change. Since I am able to do textures on my own I will try to do it or die trying. I'm sorry for the skybox also. It's not made by me but some dude named Mark Tven who you can find on gamebanana.

So this map still needs very much work and it still misses sounds and some effects that I would like to create this map. They will be added later when I have time. For now I'm going to focus on kickback projects and fixing this map. Let's see what I can accomplish during Christmas break.

Thank you for everyone who were testing and especially those who gave feedback.
And sorry for not adding pictures.